The history

The history of the harmonium

More than 3,000 years from a Chinese mouth organ with tiny bamboo reeds, through the parlours and churches of Europe, to the hand-pumped box that sings with India's temples, gurdwaras, qawwalis and film songs.

A harmonium makes sound with free reeds: thin metal tongues that swing back and forth through a slot when air pushes past them. The idea began in China and Southeast Asia, reached Europe in the 1700s, and became a keyboard instrument with bellows in France. Then Indian makers shrank it, put the bellows on the back, and made it an instrument you play sitting on the floor, where it became so loved that some people tried to ban it.

3,300+
years
29
moments
10
people
9
places

c. 14th to 12th century BCE

Earliest mention of free-reed mouth organs

Oracle bones, China

c. 433 BCE

Oldest surviving free-reed instruments

Six sheng, tomb of Marquis Yi of Zeng, China

1780

Free-reed talking machine

Christian Gottlieb Kratzenstein, St Petersburg

1840 (some say 1842)

Patent for the harmonium

Alexandre Debain, Paris

1846

Suction bellows patent

Jeremiah Carhart, USA

by 1875

Indian hand-pumped harmonium

Dwarkanath Ghose, Calcutta

1911

Harmonium tuned for the 22 shrutis

Ernest Clements and K. B. Deval

2006

Harmonium player given the Padma Shri

Mehmood Dhaulpuri (widely described as the first)

c. 14th to 12th century BCEReeds you blow

1500 BCE – 1780

Reeds you blow

In China and Southeast Asia people play mouth organs like the sheng and the khaen, where breath makes little free reeds sing inside bamboo pipes.

1300 BCE

c. 14th to 12th century BCE

The sheng: the first free reeds

Musicians of Shang dynasty ChinaNorthern China

Mouth organs called sheng and yu are mentioned on oracle bones from about 3,000 years ago. A sheng has bamboo pipes standing in a wind chest, and each pipe hides a tiny reed that swings freely through a slot. Cousins such as the khaen of Laos use the same trick.

Why it mattered. Every harmonium, accordion and harmonica still uses this free reed idea.

433 BCE

c. 433 BCE

Mouth organs buried with a marquis

Marquis Yi of ZengSuizhou, Hubei, China

When the tomb of Marquis Yi of Zeng was dug up in 1978, it held a whole orchestra, including six sheng made from gourds and pipes. Water had filled the tomb and kept the instruments safe for about 2,400 years. Their reeds were made of bamboo.

Why it mattered. They are some of the oldest free-reed instruments that survive.

1780 – 1955

Europe's reed organs

European inventors put free reeds inside boxes with keyboards and bellows. The French pressure harmonium and the American suction organ fill churches and homes, and scientists use harmoniums to study tuning.

1780

A machine that says its vowels

Christian Gottlieb KratzensteinSt Petersburg, Russia

The Imperial Academy of Sciences in St Petersburg offered a prize for explaining how we make vowel sounds. Kratzenstein won in 1780 with pipes shaped like mouths, each sounded by a free reed, that could say A, E, I, O and U. It is one of the first talking machines.

Why it mattered. It showed Europe how useful the free reed could be.

1790

from 1790

Free reeds join the church organ

Abbé Georg Joseph Vogler, inspired by organ builder KirsnikRotterdam, Netherlands, and other cities

In 1788 the travelling musician Abbé Vogler met Kirsnik, an organ builder who put free reeds in organ pipes, in St Petersburg. From 1790 Vogler added free-reed stops to about 30 organs around Europe. He also built his own touring organ, the orchestrion.

Why it mattered. It carried the free reed from a curiosity into real instruments.

1810

c. 1810

An organ that can get louder and softer

Gabriel-Joseph GreniéParis, France

Grenié built the orgue expressif, a small organ with free reeds. He showed it in 1810, though the 1911 Britannica says his first one was finished in 1812. When the player pushed more air, the reeds sounded louder, which a normal organ pipe cannot do without going out of tune.

Why it mattered. Control over the air pressure became the harmonium's special power.

1840

9 August 1840 (some sources say 1842)

The harmonium gets its name

Alexandre DebainParis, France

Debain patented a keyboard instrument with free reeds and foot-pumped bellows and called it the harmonium. He put several sets of reeds with different tone colours on one keyboard, chosen with stops. The 1911 Britannica and most sources give 1840 for the patent, though a few say 1842.

Why it mattered. Almost every reed organ made afterwards follows his basic plan.

1846

28 December 1846

America sucks instead of blows

Jeremiah CarhartBuffalo, New York, USA

Carhart patented a bellows that pulls air in through the reeds instead of pushing it out through them. Melodeons with suction bellows soon spread through American homes. After 1885 Mason & Hamlin also adopted suction, and it became the American standard, while the French harmonium kept pushing air.

Why it mattered. It split reed organs into two families: pressure harmoniums and suction organs.

1854

1854 to 1855

Double expression

Victor MustelParis, France

Mustel, a carpenter from Le Havre, patented his double expression in 1854. Knee levers let the player make the bass and the treble louder or softer on their own. His harmonium won a first-class medal at the Paris Exposition of 1855, and Mustel harmoniums became among the most admired in Europe.

Why it mattered. It let players shape the sound almost like a singer.

1861

A reed organ in every parlour

Mason & Hamlin, Estey and many other firmsBoston, Massachusetts, and Brattleboro, Vermont, USA

Mason & Hamlin, founded in Boston in 1854, launched its American organ in 1861 and showed it in Paris in 1867. Between the 1850s and 1920s, several million reed organs and melodeons were made in the United States and Canada. Estey alone made about half a million.

Why it mattered. The reed organ became the ordinary family's keyboard, long before pianos were cheap.

1863

1863 to 1873

Scientists tune harmoniums to pure intervals

Hermann von Helmholtz; Robert BosanquetHeidelberg, Germany, and London, England

In his 1863 book On the Sensations of Tone, Helmholtz used a harmonium with 24 notes to the octave, tuned so its chords were perfectly pure. In 1872 to 1873 Bosanquet had a harmonium built with 53 notes to the octave. Steady reeds made harmoniums perfect for hearing tiny differences in tuning.

Why it mattered. It showed that the usual 12 equal notes are a compromise, the same worry later raised in India.

1878

A famous piece for harmonium

Antonín DvořákPrague, Bohemia (now Czech Republic)

Dvořák wrote his Bagatelles for two violins, cello and harmonium. His friend's flat had no piano, only a harmonium, so he wrote for that. It was first played there in February 1879.

Why it mattered. It shows how common the harmonium was in European homes.

1955

mid-1950s

The West moves on

Estey Organ CompanyBrattleboro, Vermont, USA

Electronic organs appeared in the 1930s, and reed organs started to fade in Europe and America. Estey, the last big North American maker, stopped making reed organs in the mid-1950s. By then India had become the harmonium's real home.

Why it mattered. The instrument almost vanished in the West just as it thrived in South Asia.

1860 – 1940

Made in India

The harmonium arrives with missionaries and traders. A Calcutta maker turns it into a small, hand-pumped box for floor playing, and it spreads to theatre, temples, gurdwaras and music schools.

1860

mid-19th century; 1860

The harmonium reaches India

Missionaries, traders and the Tagore familyKolkata (Calcutta), India

Portable reed organs came to India in the mid-1800s, carried by missionaries, chaplains and traders to accompany hymns. In 1860 Dwijendranath Tagore used an imported one in his private theatre in Calcutta. Nobody knows exactly where in India the first one arrived.

Why it mattered. It planted a European church instrument in a land with a very different music.

1874

A harmonium handbook in Bengal

Sourindro Mohun TagoreKolkata (Calcutta), India

S. M. Tagore, a music scholar who ran a music school, published Harmonium Sutra, a guide to playing the harmonium with an Indian notation. Early music schools across North India taught the harmonium to large numbers of students.

Why it mattered. Students wanted harmoniums, which gave makers a reason to build one for Indian music.

1875

by 1875

The hand-pumped harmonium

Dwarkanath Ghose (Dwarkin & Son)Lower Chitpur Road, Kolkata (Calcutta), India

Dwarkanath Ghose started a music business in Calcutta in 1875, the firm later called Dwarkin. He is widely credited with the Indian harmonium: a small box you pump by hand from the back, played sitting on the floor with singers and drummers. He made it simpler and tougher, and added drone stops for Indian music.

Why it mattered. This is the design almost every Indian harmonium still follows.

1902

Theatre carries it south

A Parsi theatre troupe; the twin brothers Nanji and MahanjiMysore, India

Parsi theatre companies used the harmonium to accompany songs on stage all over India. For the coronation of Krishnaraja Wadiyar IV in 1902, a troupe brought harmoniums to Mysore. Two harmonium players kept by the king were among the first to teach it in Carnatic music.

Why it mattered. Travelling theatre spread the harmonium faster than any school could.

1906

c. 1905–1908

Kirtan at the Golden Temple

Ragis (kirtan singers) of Darbar SahibAmritsar, Punjab, India

The harmonium is thought to have entered kirtan at the Golden Temple in the early 1900s, probably between 1905 and 1908. Over the next century it replaced most of the older string instruments in Sikh devotional singing. Today ragi groups sing there for about 20 hours a day.

Why it mattered. It became the sound of Sikh worship for millions of people.

1910

The harmonium in Marathi musical theatre

Govindrao TembeMaharashtra, India

Govindrao Tembe, a largely self-taught harmonium player, composed the music for the play Manapman in 1910. Natya sangeet, the song-filled Marathi stage, used the harmonium as its main instrument, following pioneers like Bhaiyya Ganpatrao. Tembe later wrote music for the first Marathi talkie film in 1932.

Why it mattered. Theatre and then film songs made the harmonium part of everyday Indian music.

1911

1911; shown in 1916

A harmonium for the 22 shrutis

Ernest Clements and Krishnaji Ballal DevalLondon, England, and Baroda (Vadodara), India

Deval measured the notes of the singer Abdul Karim Khan and argued they matched the ancient Indian idea of 22 shrutis, or microtones. With Ernest Clements he designed a shruti harmonium tuned to pure ratios, which was patented in London in 1911. It was shown at the All India Music Conference in Baroda in 1916 but did not catch on.

Why it mattered. It was the first attempt to make the harmonium fit Indian tuning instead of banning it.

1912

c. 1912 (widely quoted)

The bane of Indian music

Rabindranath TagoreBengal, India

Tagore had played the harmonium in his youth, as his own memoirs describe. Later he wrote the famous line calling it that bane of Indian music, and said he practised with a tanpura so as not to be a slave to the keyboard. The harmonium was kept out of his school at Santiniketan for a long time.

Why it mattered. His words made the harmonium a symbol in the fight over what Indian music should sound like.

1914

A British scholar calls it a menace

Arthur Henry Fox StrangwaysLondon, England

In his book The Music of Hindostan, Fox Strangways called the harmonium a serious menace to Indian music. He said it was out of tune with itself and would spoil singers' ears. He also noted it had already reached the remotest parts of India.

Why it mattered. His book spread the idea that the harmonium's fixed notes did not belong in ragas.

1938 – 1971

Banned and beloved

Critics say its fixed notes do not suit Indian music. All India Radio bans it for about 30 years, while musicians go on playing it everywhere else.

1940

1 March 1940

All India Radio bans the harmonium

Lionel Fielden, Controller of Broadcasting, after a campaign by John FouldsDelhi, India

The composer John Foulds, who ran Western music at All India Radio, wrote in 1938 that the harmonium's tuning did not fit Indian music. Soon after, the radio banned it from its Indian music programmes, and the ban took effect on 1 March 1940. Protesting musicians staged a mock funeral and buried eleven harmoniums.

Why it mattered. For three decades, India's national radio refused to play its most popular accompanying instrument.

1971

The ban is partly lifted

All India Radio and the Sangeet Natak AkademiNew Delhi, India

After a 1970 meeting of music experts, All India Radio allowed top grade singers and qawwali groups to use the harmonium as an accompaniment. Solo harmonium recitals stayed off its main music programmes for many years after. One critic argued the harmonium should not be treated as an untouchable.

Why it mattered. The harmonium was back on air, but still not trusted as a solo instrument.

1971 – today

A voice of its own

The ban eases, qawwali carries the harmonium around the world, Indian masters win national honours for it, and inventors build harmoniums that can play India's finer notes.

1972

The samvadini

Manohar ChimoteMaharashtra, India

Manohar Chimote worked for years to play full classical ragas as harmonium solos, with slow openings and fast strokes like a sitar. He retuned and revoiced his instrument and in 1972 gave it a new name: samvadini, the one that creates harmony.

Why it mattered. It was a bold claim that the harmonium could be a classical solo voice.

1975

Qawwali reaches Carnegie Hall

The Sabri BrothersNew York, USA

Ghulam Farid Sabri and Maqbool Ahmed Sabri from Karachi sang and played harmonium in their qawwali group. In 1975 they performed at Carnegie Hall in New York, said to be the first qawwali performance in the West. Their harmonium drones and rolling rhythms amazed new audiences.

Why it mattered. It carried the harmonium's sound far beyond South Asia.

1985

Nusrat's party wins over the world

Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and Farrukh Fateh Ali KhanWOMAD festival, Mersea Island, England

Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan's qawwali group sang for hours at the WOMAD festival in 1985, and it launched his world career. His brother Farrukh played lead harmonium in the group for more than 25 years. Fans in England called him the King of the Harmonium.

Why it mattered. Millions of people around the world first heard the Indian harmonium through qawwali.

2006

National honours for harmonium players

Mehmood Dhaulpuri, Appa Jalgaonkar and Tulsidas BorkarNew Delhi, India

Mehmood Dhaulpuri accompanied great singers such as Bhimsen Joshi, Kishori Amonkar and Girija Devi. In 2006 he received the Padma Shri, and he is widely described as the first harmonium player to get it. Appa Jalgaonkar had won a Sangeet Natak Akademi Award in 2000, and Tulsidas Borkar received the Padma Shri in 2016.

Why it mattered. India's government was now honouring the instrument its radio had once banned.

2006

December 2006 or 2007

The 22-shruti harmonium

Vidyadhar OkePune, India

Doctor and musicologist Vidyadhar Oke built a harmonium with small knobs under the keys that let each note be nudged to the right shruti. Singer Rahul Deshpande used it on stage at the Sawai Gandharva festival in Pune, in December 2006 or 2007 depending on the source. Oke later received an Indian patent for it.

Why it mattered. It tries to fix the very tuning problem that got the harmonium banned.

2022

3 May 2022

A call to bring back the strings

Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Harpreet Singh; the SGPCAmritsar, Punjab, India

The Akal Takht asked the SGPC, which runs the Golden Temple, to bring back traditional string instruments in kirtan within three years, calling the harmonium colonial. The SGPC said it would revive the strings step by step at the Golden Temple, but had no plans to throw out the harmonium. The debate about this imported instrument is still alive.

Why it mattered. More than 140 years after Dwarkin, people still argue about whether the harmonium truly belongs.

Did you know?

A harmonium reed never hits anything: the thin brass tongue swings through its slot, chopping the air into puffs.

The French harmonium pushes air through its reeds, while the American reed organ sucks air through them.

When All India Radio banned the harmonium in 1940, protesting musicians held a mock funeral and buried eleven harmoniums.

Estey, just one American maker, built about half a million reed organs between 1846 and 1955.

Rabindranath Tagore called the harmonium the bane of Indian music, yet his own memoirs describe him singing to one.

The people

Who figured it out

Alexandre Debain

1809 – 1877 · Instrument maker · France

Patented the harmonium in Paris and gave it its name.

Victor Mustel

1815 – 1890 · Harmonium maker · France

Invented the double expression and built some of Europe's most admired harmoniums.

Dwarkanath Ghose

19th century · Instrument maker, founder of Dwarkin · India

Widely credited with the hand-pumped Indian harmonium, made by 1875.

Bhaiyya Ganpatrao

1852 – 1920 · Harmonium player and thumri composer · India

The biggest name on the harmonium around 1900, who helped bring it into Hindustani music.

Govindrao Tembe

1881 – 1955 · Harmonium player, actor and composer · India

Made the harmonium the heart of Marathi musical theatre and early film songs.

Rabindranath Tagore

1861 – 1941 · Poet and composer · India

Played the harmonium when young, then called it that bane of Indian music.

Manohar Chimote

1929 – 2012 · Harmonium soloist · India

Recast the harmonium as a classical solo instrument and named it the samvadini.

Appa Jalgaonkar

1922 – 2009 · Harmonium accompanist · India

Accompanied Bhimsen Joshi and Kumar Gandharva and won a Sangeet Natak Akademi Award in 2000.

Farrukh Fateh Ali Khan

1952 – 2003 · Qawwali harmonium player · Pakistan

Played lead harmonium for his brother Nusrat for more than 25 years.

Tulsidas Borkar

1934 – 2018 · Harmonium soloist, teacher and designer · India (Goa)

Worked to improve the instrument's tone and tuning and received the Padma Shri in 2016.

Where it happened

9 places, one idea

Sources

Where this comes from

Dates marked “c.” are approximate, and historians sometimes disagree about who was first. If you spot a mistake, tell us.

  1. Harmonium Wikipedia
  2. Pump organ Wikipedia
  3. Indian harmonium Wikipedia
  4. Sheng (instrument) Wikipedia
  5. Sheng The Metropolitan Museum of Art
  6. Tomb of Marquis Yi of Zeng Wikipedia
  7. Tomb of Marquis Yi of Zeng Hubei Provincial Government
  8. Khene Wikipedia
  9. Khaen music of the Lao people UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage
  10. Christian Gottlieb Kratzenstein Wikipedia
  11. Georg Joseph Vogler Wikipedia
  12. Harmonium (1911 Encyclopædia Britannica) Wikisource
  13. Alexandre Debain Wikipedia
  14. History of the reed organ harmoniums.com
  15. Carhart, Needham & Co. Reed Organ (Melodeon) Smithsonian National Museum of American History
  16. Melodeon (organ) Wikipedia
  17. Mason & Hamlin Wikipedia
  18. Estey Organ Wikipedia
  19. Mustel, Victor (A Dictionary of Music and Musicians) Wikisource
  20. Harmonium, Victor and Auguste Mustel The Metropolitan Museum of Art
  21. Sensations of Tone Wikipedia
  22. On the Sensations of Tone (full text, Ellis translation) Internet Archive
  23. Bosanquet's Enharmonic Harmonium Science Museum Group
  24. Bagatelles (Dvořák) Wikipedia
  25. That Ban(e) of Indian Music: Hearing Politics in the Harmonium (Matthew Rahaim, Journal of Asian Studies, 2011) University of Minnesota
  26. That Ban(e) of Indian Music (author's copy) Matthew Rahaim
  27. Dwarkin Wikipedia
  28. The harmonium was born in Europe, so how did it become synonymous with Indian music? Scroll.in
  29. The Rise and the Sudden Fall of the Harmonium Open Magazine
  30. My Reminiscences (Rabindranath Tagore) Project Gutenberg
  31. The Music of Hindostan (A. H. Fox Strangways, 1914) Internet Archive
  32. The Story of the World's First Shruti-Harmonium 22 Shruti (Vidyadhar Oke)
  33. John Foulds Wikipedia
  34. Harmonium, RK Bijapure and Akashvani's infamous ban India Art Review
  35. India's Musical Menace The Wilson Quarterly
  36. Govindrao Tembe Wikipedia
  37. Govindrao Tembe Indian Culture Portal, Ministry of Culture, Government of India
  38. Bhaiyya Ganpatrao Wikipedia
  39. About Samvadini Pandit Manohar Chimote
  40. Sabri Brothers Wikipedia
  41. Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan Wikipedia
  42. Riding a wave of emotion: Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan at WOMAD 1985 Real World Records
  43. Farrukh Fateh Ali Khan Wikipedia
  44. Mehmood Dhaulpuri Wikipedia
  45. Appa Jalgaonkar Wikipedia
  46. Tulsidas Borkar Wikipedia
  47. Renowned harmonium exponent Pt. Tulsidas Borkar dead Business Standard (IANS)
  48. Padma Awards Government of India
  49. Vidyadhar Oke Wikipedia
  50. The Marquis Yi of Zeng: Lacquer Objects Hubei Provincial Museum on Google Arts & Culture
  51. What Akal Takht must know about harmonium and music before banishing it from Golden Temple ThePrint
  52. SGPC: No plans to phase out harmonium for now The Tribune
  53. Mouth organ Wikipedia
  54. Free reed aerophone Wikipedia
  55. Qawwali Wikipedia
  56. Kirtan Wikipedia
  57. Arthur Henry Fox Strangways Wikipedia
  58. Rahul Deshpande Wikipedia

That's the history. Now see how it works.