The history

The history of film editing

A century and more from a jammed camera in Paris to editing a Hollywood epic on a Mac.

The first films were single shots. Within a few years, film-makers found that cutting between shots could leap across space and time, build suspense and even create feelings that were in no single shot. Machines like the Moviola and the flatbed made cutting precise, rebels like Godard broke the rules on purpose, and computers finally let editors change any cut in seconds.

126
years
27
moments
9
people
7
places

1900

Close-ups cut into a scene

George Albert Smith, England

1909

Cross-cutting for suspense

D. W. Griffith, USA

1924

Upright editing machine (Moviola)

Iwan Serrurier, USA

1971

Non-linear editor (CMX 600)

CMX Systems, USA

1997

Digital edit to win the editing Oscar

Walter Murch, The English Patient

2003

Major Hollywood film cut on Final Cut Pro

Walter Murch, Cold Mountain

c. 1896Discovering the cut

1895 – 1917

Discovering the cut

Film-makers learn that shots can be joined: close-ups, dissolves, action across cuts and cross-cutting for suspense.

1896

c. 1896

A camera jams, and a trick is born

Georges MélièsParis, France

Méliès said his camera jammed while filming a Paris street. When he projected the film, a bus seemed to turn into a hearse. He began stopping the camera and splicing film on purpose to make things appear and vanish.

Why it mattered. It showed that film could be cut and joined to change what the audience believes they saw.

1900

A close-up cut into a scene

George Albert SmithBrighton, England

In Grandma's Reading Glass, a boy looks through a magnifying glass, and Smith cuts to big circular close-ups of what he sees: a watch, a canary, his grandmother's eye.

Why it mattered. It is one of the earliest films to cut between a wide shot and close-ups from a character's point of view.

1901

A rescue that carries across the cuts

James WilliamsonBrighton, England

Fire! follows a fire from the street to a burning bedroom and back outside, across several shots. A firefighter carries a rescued person out of one shot and into the next.

Why it mattered. It showed how action can carry on across a cut, the seed of continuity editing.

1902

Dissolves join the scenes

Georges MélièsMontreuil, France

A Trip to the Moon links its scenes with dissolves, one picture melting into the next, as its scientists fly to the Moon and back.

Why it mattered. It made the dissolve part of cinema's grammar long before editing machines existed.

1903

December 1903

The Great Train Robbery

Edwin S. Porter, Edison Manufacturing CompanyNew Jersey, USA

Porter's 12-minute western tells its story in about 14 shots, cutting between the robbers, the train and the telegraph office. It was a huge hit in the new nickelodeon theatres.

Why it mattered. Cutting between places that are far apart helped audiences learn to follow a story told in separate shots.

1909

Cross-cutting builds suspense

D. W. Griffith, BiographNew York, USA

In The Lonely Villa, robbers break into a house while the father races home. Griffith cuts back and forth between them, faster and faster, until the rescue.

Why it mattered. Cross-cutting between two lines of action became one of the most powerful tools for suspense.

1916

Four stories, 2,500 years apart

D. W. GriffithLos Angeles, USA

Intolerance cuts between four stories set in ancient Babylon, the time of Jesus, 16th-century France and modern America, building all four towards their climaxes together.

Why it mattered. It pushed cross-cutting further than anyone before and deeply influenced Soviet film-makers.

1918 – 1929

Montage

Soviet film-makers turn editing into a theory of meaning, while Hollywood gets its first editing machine.

1920

c. 1918–1921

The Kuleshov experiment

Lev Kuleshov, with actor Ivan MosjoukineMoscow, Russia

Kuleshov is said to have cut the same expressionless close-up next to shots of a bowl of soup, a girl in a coffin and a woman on a divan. As Pudovkin told it, viewers praised the actor's hunger, grief and desire. No footage survives.

Why it mattered. It suggested that meaning comes from how shots are joined, not only from what is in them. Modern studies find a real but modest effect.

1924

The Moviola

Iwan SerrurierLos Angeles, USA

Serrurier turned his home movie projector into an upright editing machine with a small viewer. The first one went to Douglas Fairbanks's studio.

Why it mattered. Editors could now watch film at any speed and find the exact frame to cut. Moviolas stayed the Hollywood standard until the 1970s.

1925

December 1925

Battleship Potemkin and the Odessa Steps

Sergei EisensteinMoscow, USSR

Eisenstein's film about a 1905 naval mutiny cuts together hundreds of short shots. In the Odessa Steps sequence, soldiers march down a long flight of steps into a fleeing crowd, and the editing stretches a few moments of terror into minutes.

Why it mattered. It became the most studied example of montage: meaning and emotion made by shots colliding.

1927

A film made only from old footage

Esfir ShubMoscow, USSR

Shub searched archives for old newsreels and home movies of the Russian royal family and edited them into The Fall of the Romanov Dynasty.

Why it mattered. She showed that an editor can create a new story from footage shot by others, the root of the compilation documentary.

1929

Man with a Movie Camera

Dziga Vertov and editor Elizaveta SvilovaKyiv, Odesa and Moscow, USSR

A city symphony with no story and no actors, built from thousands of shots, with fast cutting, split screens and freeze frames. Svilova, the editor, even appears in the film at her editing bench.

Why it mattered. It shows off almost every editing trick of the silent era in one film.

1930 – 1959

Invisible editing

Sound films and studio systems perfect continuity editing, cut on Moviolas and flatbed tables.

1935

1930s

Flatbed editing tables

Steenbeck and KEMHamburg, Germany

German companies built editing tables that lay the film flat on spinning plates, with a screen and separate picture and sound tracks. They came into wide use in the United States in the 1970s.

Why it mattered. Flatbeds made it easy to run picture and sound together, forwards and back, and became the classic editing bench.

1953

An editor who became a great director

Hrishikesh MukherjeeBombay, India

Mukherjee edited Bimal Roy's Do Bigha Zamin, a landmark of Indian realist cinema, before going on to direct films such as Anand.

Why it mattered. Indian cinema has long drawn directors from the editing room, where they learn how scenes really work.

1960 – 1988

Breaking the rules

New waves make cuts visible on purpose, and the first computer editors appear.

1960

March 1960

Breathless and the jump cut

Jean-Luc Godard, editor Cécile DecugisParis, France

Godard's first feature cut chunks out of continuous shots, so the characters seem to jump forward in time. Mainstream editors had worked hard to hide such cuts.

Why it mattered. It made the jump cut a deliberate style. Today it is everywhere, from music videos to vlogs.

1962

A matchstick becomes a desert sunrise

Anne V. Coates, for David LeanLondon, England

In Lawrence of Arabia, Lawrence blows out a match and the film cuts straight to the sun rising over the desert. Coates won the Academy Award for editing.

Why it mattered. It became one of the most admired match cuts in film.

1968

From a bone to a spacecraft

Stanley Kubrick, editor Ray LovejoyBorehamwood, England

In 2001: A Space Odyssey, an early human throws a bone into the air, and a match cut turns it into a satellite in orbit, jumping millions of years in one frame.

Why it mattered. It showed how a single match cut can carry a huge leap in time and meaning.

1971

The first non-linear editor

CMX Systems (CBS and Memorex)California, USA

The CMX 600 stored video on disk drives the size of washing machines, holding about half an hour of footage, and let editors jump to any shot instantly.

Why it mattered. It was the first step towards editing on computers, where you can change any cut without re-splicing everything after it.

1984

EditDroid

Lucasfilm and The Droid WorksCalifornia, USA

EditDroid used LaserDiscs and a computer to find shots quickly, with an early on-screen timeline. It was shown at the NAB trade show in 1984 but sold only a few systems.

Why it mattered. Many of its ideas, like the timeline, returned in later digital editors.

1989 – today

The digital cutting room

Avid, Premiere, Final Cut and others replace film benches, and editing reaches every laptop and phone.

1989

Avid Media Composer

Avid TechnologyMassachusetts, USA

Avid showed its computer editing system in 1989. Editors could cut with digitised copies of the footage, then send a list of their decisions to finish the film.

Why it mattered. Media Composer became the standard for feature films and TV, and it still is in many cutting rooms.

1989

for Parinda (1989)

Renu Saluja's first National Award

Renu SalujaBombay, India

Saluja, a Film and Television Institute of India graduate, won the National Film Award for editing for Parinda, then again for Dharavi, Sardar and Godmother. She also cut Jaane Bhi Do Yaaro and 1942: A Love Story.

Why it mattered. She became one of Indian cinema's most respected editors when the job was mostly done by men. An editing award is now named after her.

1991

December 1991

Editing comes to the desktop

AdobeCalifornia, USA

Adobe Premiere let people edit video on an ordinary Apple Macintosh computer. Today's Premiere Pro is used for everything from YouTube videos to feature films.

Why it mattered. Editing software stopped being only for studios.

1995

In the Blink of an Eye

Walter MurchSan Francisco, USA

Murch's short book on editing asks why cuts work at all, and sets out his Rule of Six: emotion 51%, story 23%, rhythm 10%, eye-trace 7%, the screen's 2D plane 5% and 3D space 4%.

Why it mattered. It is still one of the most read books on editing.

1997

March 1997

A digital edit wins the Oscar

Walter MurchLos Angeles, USA

Murch's edit of The English Patient, cut on an Avid, won the Academy Award for Best Film Editing.

Why it mattered. It was the first digitally edited film to win that Oscar, and the switch from film benches to computers sped up.

1999

April 1999

Final Cut Pro

AppleCalifornia, USA

Apple released Final Cut Pro, an editor that ran on an ordinary Mac and cost far less than professional systems.

Why it mattered. Film students and independent film-makers could now edit professionally at home.

2003

Cold Mountain is cut on a Mac

Walter Murch, for Anthony MinghellaLondon, England and USA

Murch and his assistant edited 597,000 feet of film for Cold Mountain on Final Cut Pro, the first major Hollywood feature cut on it.

Why it mattered. It proved that affordable desktop software could handle a big studio film.

2022

1989–2022

A. Sreekar Prasad, editor in 17 languages

A. Sreekar PrasadChennai, India

Prasad has won National Awards for editing many times since 1989 and has cut films in 17 languages, from Dil Chahta Hai and Kannathil Muthamittal to RRR (2022).

Why it mattered. His career shows how one editor can shape films across India's many languages.

By the numbers

How long a shot lasts in popular films

Average shot duration in English-language popular films, by period, from James Cutting's 2016 study. Films now cut more than twice as often as in the early sound era.

1 min1 s 192019301940195019601970198019902000 1920: Silent films, 1915 to 1925: 7.5 s19201943: Early sound films, 1930 to 1955: 10.5 s19431973: 1960 to 1985: 7.0 s19732003: 1990 to 2015: 4.3 s2003
  1. 1920 Silent films, 1915 to 1925: 7.5 s
  2. 1943 Early sound films, 1930 to 1955: 10.5 s
  3. 1973 1960 to 1985: 7.0 s
  4. 2003 1990 to 2015: 4.3 s

Did you know?

In Kuleshov's experiment the actor's face was the same shot every time, yet viewers said he looked hungry, sad or loving.

Walter Murch's Rule of Six ranks emotion at 51%, far above keeping the 180-degree line, which gets just 5%.

Cold Mountain's editors worked through 597,000 feet of film, about 110 hours of footage at 24 frames a second.

At the pace of films from 1990 to 2015, about 4.3 seconds a shot, a two-hour film holds around 1,700 shots.

The people

Who figured it out

Georges Méliès

1861 – 1938 · Magician and film-maker · France

Turned splicing and dissolves into movie magic.

D. W. Griffith

1875 – 1948 · Director · USA

Made cross-cutting a tool for suspense.

Lev Kuleshov

1899 – 1970 · Film-maker and teacher · Russia

Showed that the cut itself can create meaning.

Sergei Eisenstein

1898 – 1948 · Director and theorist · Latvia and Russia

Built a theory of montage as shots colliding.

Esfir Shub

1894 – 1959 · Editor and director · Russian Empire and USSR

Invented the compilation film from archive footage.

Anne V. Coates

1925 – 2018 · Editor · England

Cut Lawrence of Arabia and won the Oscar.

Walter Murch

born 1943 · Editor and sound designer · USA

Wrote In the Blink of an Eye and led editing onto computers.

Renu Saluja

1952 – 2000 · Editor · India

Four National Awards for editing, including Parinda.

A. Sreekar Prasad

born 1963 · Editor · India

Many National Awards, and films in 17 languages.

Where it happened

7 places, one idea

Sources

Where this comes from

Dates marked “c.” are approximate, and historians sometimes disagree about who was first. If you spot a mistake, tell us.

  1. Georges Méliès Wikipedia
  2. A Trip to the Moon Wikipedia
  3. Grandma's Reading Glass Wikipedia
  4. Fire! (1901 film) Wikipedia
  5. The Great Train Robbery (1903 film) Wikipedia
  6. The Great Train Robbery: National Film Registry Library of Congress
  7. D. W. Griffith Wikipedia
  8. The Lonely Villa Wikipedia
  9. Intolerance (film) Wikipedia
  10. Kuleshov effect Wikipedia
  11. Barratt et al., Does the Kuleshov Effect Really Exist? (2016) Perception 45(8), SAGE Journals
  12. Moviola Wikipedia
  13. Battleship Potemkin Wikipedia
  14. Soviet montage theory Wikipedia
  15. Esfir Shub Wikipedia
  16. Man with a Movie Camera Wikipedia
  17. Flatbed editor Wikipedia
  18. Steenbeck Wikipedia
  19. Hrishikesh Mukherjee Wikipedia
  20. Breathless (1960 film) Wikipedia
  21. Jump cut Wikipedia
  22. Anne V. Coates Wikipedia
  23. Match cut Wikipedia
  24. Non-linear editing Wikipedia
  25. CMX Systems Wikipedia
  26. EditDroid Wikipedia
  27. Media Composer Wikipedia
  28. Avid Technology Wikipedia
  29. Renu Saluja Wikipedia
  30. National Film Award for Best Editing Wikipedia
  31. Adobe Premiere Pro Wikipedia
  32. In the Blink of an Eye (Murch book) Wikipedia
  33. Academy Award for Best Film Editing Wikipedia
  34. The English Patient (film) Wikipedia
  35. Final Cut Pro Wikipedia
  36. Edit This! Cold Mountain's Final Cut Post Magazine, December 2003
  37. Behind the Seen: How Walter Murch Edited Cold Mountain Using Apple's Final Cut Pro Charles Koppelman, New Riders / Peachpit, 2004
  38. A. Sreekar Prasad Wikipedia
  39. Cutting, The evolution of pace in popular movies (2016) Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications / PMC
  40. Post-classical editing (on Bordwell, Intensified Continuity, 2002) Wikipedia
  41. Walter Murch Wikipedia

That's the history. Now see how it works.